Explore what the Bible says about the nativity, wise men, King Herod, and the true meaning of Christmas.
When it comes to the Christmas story, how much of what we know is fact, and how much is influenced by tradition? Every December, nativity scenes pop up in churches, homes, and even front yards. But have you ever stopped to ask, What does the Bible say about Christmas? In our podcast episode, “Christmas Myths: Truth or Tradition?”, Caleb Adams and Chris LaCombe unpack some of the most common assumptions about Christmas and explore what Scripture actually tells us.
What Does the Bible Say About Christmas? Debunking Christmas Myths
The Christmas story is full of beautiful details, but how many of them come from Scripture, and how many are shaped by cultural traditions? From Joseph’s role to the timing of the wise men’s visit, these details matter.
Let’s look at some of the most common Christmas myths.
Joseph, Mary, and Jesus at the Manger
The Christmas story begins with Joseph and Mary—a carpenter and a young woman chosen to bring the Savior into the world. Scripture paints a picture of their obedience and humility, but there’s much we don’t know. For example, Joseph is a central figure in Jesus’ early life, yet he disappears after the temple scene in Luke 2:52. Why? Tradition fills in gaps where the Bible is silent, but it’s important not to add details that Scripture doesn’t provide. We simply don’t know what happened to Joseph.
Wise Men in the Christmas Story: Truth and Tradition
Most nativity scenes show three wise men bearing gifts, but the Bible never says how many there were. Matthew 2:1-12 mentions “wise men from the East” who brought gold, frankincense, and myrrh, leading many to assume there were three men—one for each gift. However, their actual number remains a mystery.
What’s more, these wise men didn’t arrive at the manger on the night of Christ’s birth. Scripture says they came later, likely when Jesus was a child. This detail reshapes the timeline of events but doesn’t diminish the awe of their journey or their recognition of Christ as King. Examining the wise men in the Christmas story helps us focus on truth over tradition and see their role in God’s plan.
King Herod and the Christmas Story: Tragedy and Triumph
The Christmas story is often seen as a tale of joy and peace, but the account of King Herod adds a tragic undertone. When the wise men announced the birth of a new King, Herod’s fear and pride led him to order the massacre of all male children two years old and under in Bethlehem (Matthew 2:16). This horrific act fulfilled prophecy but also reminds us of the broken world Christ came to save.
Herod’s story challenges us to reflect on how pride and fear can blind us to the work of God. What Herod meant for evil, God used for good so that even in darkness, His purposes prevailed.
Biblical Perspective on Christmas Traditions
While many Christmas traditions bring joy and meaning to the season, it’s crucial to consider a biblical perspective. From nativity scenes to Christmas carols, our cultural customs can either enrich our faith or obscure the true message of Christ’s birth.
For example, reflecting on the shepherds, the wise men, and Jesus being born in a manger brings the focus back to Scripture. These details reveal the humility and divinity of Christ and remind us why we celebrate. Christmas isn’t just about traditions; it’s about the fulfillment of God’s promise to send a Savior.
The True Meaning of Christmas
One of the most striking images from our conversation is the connection between Jesus’ birth and His mission as the Lamb of God. Outside Bethlehem, shepherds tended flocks of sheep destined for the Passover sacrifice. These were likely the same shepherds visited by angels who announced Jesus’ birth. The Lamb of God was born in a place where sacrificial lambs were raised—a detail that foreshadows His ultimate sacrifice for our sins.
This imagery deepens the meaning of Christmas. It’s not just a celebration of a baby’s birth but the arrival of the Savior who would take away the sin of the world.
Putting it All Together
The Christmas story invites us to wonder and worship. But it also challenges us to look beyond tradition and focus on the truth of Scripture. Take some time today to marvel at the humility of Christ, the sovereignty of God, and the joy of so great a salvation.
Listen to the Full Podcast
For a deeper dive into these topics and more, listen to our episode, “Christmas Myths: Truth or Tradition?”